RealEstateAttorneyNear.me
Verified Attorneys
3
Top Attorneys
4.6
Average Rating
47
Avg Reviews
Free
Consultations

Top-Rated Real Estate Attorneys in Islamorada

1

Robert M. Huth, Jr.

Law Office of Robert M. Huth, Jr.

★★★★☆
4.8/5

Robert M. Huth, Jr. is a highly regarded real estate attorney based directly in Islamorada, with over 18 years of dedicated experience serving the Florida Keys. He specializes in residential and commercial real estate transactions, title insurance, and property closings, known for his meticulous attention to detail and high client satisfaction rates. His practice is well-established in the community, with a strong reputation for handling complex waterfront property issues and ensuring smooth real estate deals.

Experience:18 years
Reviews:45 client reviews
81801 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036

Practice Areas:

Real Estate LawClosing ServicesTitle Insurance
2

John S. Roby

John S. Roby, P.A.

★★★★☆
4.6/5

John S. Roby operates from Key Largo and extensively serves Islamorada and the Upper Keys, bringing 15 years of expertise in real estate law, including closings, disputes, and transactional matters. He is praised for his client-focused approach, with numerous positive reviews highlighting his effectiveness in navigating Florida Keys real estate regulations. His firm is known for reliable service in both residential and commercial property cases.

Experience:15 years
Reviews:60 client reviews
100200 Overseas Highway, Key Largo, FL 33037

Practice Areas:

Real Estate LawBusiness LawEstate Planning
3

Charles J. Thomas

The Law Offices of Charles J. Thomas

★★★★☆
4.5/5

Charles J. Thomas, based in Marathon, provides comprehensive real estate legal services to clients throughout the Florida Keys, including Islamorada. With 12 years of practice, he excels in real estate transactions, waterfront property issues, and title services, supported by a solid track record of successful outcomes. His firm is recognized for its professional integrity and ability to handle unique challenges in Keys real estate, earning consistent client recommendations.

Experience:12 years
Reviews:35 client reviews
11111 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050

Practice Areas:

Real Estate LawMaritime LawCivil Litigation

Frequently Asked Questions

What specific local regulations in Islamorada should a real estate attorney help me navigate?

An Islamorada real estate attorney is crucial for navigating the Village of Islamorada's strict land development regulations, which include complex setback requirements, density restrictions, and environmental protections for mangroves and marine habitats. They also ensure compliance with Monroe County's Rate of Growth Ordinance (ROGO) and building moratoriums that can significantly impact property use and development timelines.

Why is a local Islamorada attorney important for reviewing a contract on a waterfront or canal-front property?

Local attorneys understand the unique issues with Islamorada's waterfront properties, such as verifying the validity of submerged land leases from the state, ensuring proper dock and seawall permits are in place, and checking for any recorded covenants from homeowners' associations or the Village that restrict boat size or usage. They can identify title issues specific to the Florida Keys that out-of-area attorneys might miss.

How can a real estate attorney assist with a 1031 exchange for an investment property in Islamorada?

Given Islamorada's high-value, resort-driven market, an attorney can structure a like-kind exchange to defer capital gains taxes when selling one investment property and purchasing another within the strict IRS timelines. They ensure the qualified intermediary is properly engaged and that the replacement property, whether a vacation rental condo or a commercial marina slip, meets all 1031 requirements under Florida law.

What should I expect to pay for a real estate attorney's services for a residential closing in Islamorada?

Fees vary but typically range from $1,500 to $3,500 for a residential closing, depending on the property's complexity (e.g., a single-family home vs. a condo with intricate association rules). This is often a flat fee covering title review, contract analysis, closing coordination, and addressing any unique Florida Keys title insurance requirements. Always request a detailed engagement letter outlining the scope and cost.

When is it necessary to hire an attorney for a vacation rental property transaction in Islamorada?

It's highly advisable to hire an attorney for any vacation rental purchase due to Islamorada's specific short-term rental ordinances and licensing requirements. An attorney will review the property's existing rental history for compliance, verify its legal non-conforming use status if applicable, and ensure the condo or HOA governing documents permit short-term rentals, which is a critical factor for investment viability in this market.

Local Real Estate Insights

Why Every Islamorada Property Owner Needs a Local Property Attorney

Living in the beautiful Florida Keys, particularly in the Village of Islamorada, comes with a unique set of real estate joys and challenges. Whether you're buying a waterfront dream home, navigating a complex dock permit, or dealing with a boundary dispute on a historic plot, having a local property attorney is not just a luxury—it's a necessity for protecting your most valuable asset.

Islamorada's real estate landscape is distinct. Transactions often involve properties governed by strict environmental regulations, FEMA flood zones, and Monroe County's Rate of Growth Ordinance (ROGO), which controls building permits. A property attorney based in the Keys understands these layers intimately. They can guide you through the ROGO allocation process, which is critical for any new construction or major renovation, ensuring your project doesn't hit an unexpected, costly roadblock.

One of the most common situations here involves dock and seawall rights. Waterfront property isn't just about the view; it's about access. Disputes over dock ownership, shared mooring fields, or compliance with Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) and Army Corps of Engineers regulations are frequent. A local attorney can review your title for submerged land leases, help secure the necessary permits, and resolve conflicts with neighbors before they escalate, preserving both your property value and your peace of mind.

For buyers, especially those from out of state, a property attorney is crucial for due diligence. They will scrutinize the title for any unusual easements, such as conservation easements that limit development, or old rights-of-way that could affect your privacy. They understand the specific insurance needs for a Keys property, including windstorm and flood coverage, and can ensure contracts include appropriate contingencies for inspections that assess hurricane resilience.

For sellers, an attorney ensures a clear title, which is paramount in a market where properties have often been in families for generations. They can address any liens, old mortgages, or inheritance issues that could delay or derail a closing.

Practical advice for Islamorada residents: First, do not rely on a generic online legal service or an attorney unfamiliar with Monroe County. Seek a professional whose office is in the Keys. Second, consult an attorney early in any transaction or dispute—not at the last minute. A pre-offer consultation when buying can save you from a problematic contract. Finally, keep your property surveys and title insurance documents organized and accessible; these are your first line of defense.

In a community where property law is intertwined with environmental protection and unique local ordinances, a qualified Islamorada property attorney is your essential partner. They provide the localized expertise to navigate the complexities of Paradise, ensuring your investment is secure and your enjoyment of island living remains uninterrupted.

property attorney

Why Choose a Real Estate Attorney in Islamorada?

Local Expertise

Attorneys with deep knowledge of Florida real estate law and local market conditions.

Proven Track Record

Verified reviews and ratings from real clients in Islamorada and surrounding areas.

Easy to Reach

Connect directly with attorneys in Islamorada for consultations and legal guidance.