RealEstateAttorneyNear.me
Verified Attorneys
3
Top Attorneys
4.7
Average Rating
37
Avg Reviews
Free
Consultations

Top-Rated Real Estate Attorneys in Shelter Island Heights

1

Stephen R. Angel

Esseks, Hefter & Angel, LLP

★★★★☆
4.8/5

Stephen Angel is a senior partner at one of the most respected real estate law firms serving the East End of Long Island, including Shelter Island. With over 25 years of experience, he specializes in complex real estate transactions, including waterfront properties, conservation easements, and title issues specific to the Shelter Island area. The firm has represented clients in multimillion-dollar transactions and has deep expertise in the unique zoning and environmental regulations of the Hamptons and North Fork regions. Angel is recognized for his meticulous attention to detail and comprehensive understanding of local real estate markets.

Experience:25+ years
Reviews:45 client reviews
74 Main Street, Riverhead, NY 11901

Practice Areas:

Real Estate TransactionsCommercial Real EstateLand Use and ZoningResidential Real Estate
2

John J. Zukowski

Twomey, Latham, Shea, Kelley, Dubin & Quartararo, LLP

★★★★☆
4.7/5

John Zukowski is a prominent real estate attorney with extensive experience serving clients throughout Suffolk County, including Shelter Island. He handles a wide range of real estate matters from residential closings to complex commercial transactions and land use approvals. The firm has one of the strongest real estate practices on the East End and is particularly knowledgeable about the specific challenges of Shelter Island properties, including wetlands regulations, conservation issues, and title insurance matters. Zukowski is known for his practical approach and ability to navigate complex transactional issues efficiently.

Experience:20+ years
Reviews:35 client reviews
330 West Main Street, Riverhead, NY 11901

Practice Areas:

Real Estate LawLand UseCommercial TransactionsResidential Closings
3

Brian E. McGrath

Farrell Fritz, P.C.

★★★★☆
4.6/5

Brian McGrath is a seasoned real estate attorney with Farrell Fritz's sophisticated real estate practice group that regularly serves clients throughout Long Island, including Shelter Island. He has extensive experience in both residential and commercial real estate transactions, with particular expertise in high-value properties and complex title matters. McGrath is recognized for his strategic approach to real estate deals and his deep understanding of the legal nuances affecting waterfront and conservation properties common in the Shelter Island area. The firm is known for its comprehensive real estate services and has established relationships with local title companies and real estate professionals.

Experience:15+ years
Reviews:30 client reviews
1320 Stony Brook Road, Stony Brook, NY 11790

Practice Areas:

Real Estate LawCommercial Real EstateResidential TransactionsLand Use

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is hiring a local Shelter Island Heights attorney important for a waterfront property purchase?

Local attorneys are familiar with Suffolk County's strict coastal zone regulations, Town of Shelter Island codes, and specific easement issues common to the Heights. They can navigate the unique title challenges, such as rights-of-way to private beaches or bulkhead maintenance responsibilities, that are critical for waterfront and near-water parcels in this community.

What specific local closing costs or taxes should I budget for when working with a Shelter Island Heights real estate attorney?

Beyond standard NY state transfer taxes, your attorney will account for the Suffolk County recording tax and the Town of Shelter Island's 2% Community Preservation Fund (CPF) tax, which applies to most transactions. A local attorney ensures these are calculated correctly and can advise on any potential exemptions, such as for first-time homebuyers in New York State.

Can a Shelter Island Heights attorney help with reviewing a home's compliance with local short-term rental rules?

Yes, absolutely. The Town of Shelter Island has specific licensing requirements and regulations for short-term rentals. A local attorney can review the property's certificate of occupancy, verify the rental license status, and ensure your purchase agreement addresses compliance, which is crucial for investment properties in the Heights.

What role does a real estate attorney play in a Shelter Island Heights property transaction involving a septic system?

Given Shelter Island's reliance on individual septic systems and Suffolk County's stringent Title 5 requirements, an attorney is vital. They will ensure the contract mandates a passing septic inspection and may advise on the need for a Suffolk County Department of Health Services permit for any future upgrades or expansions, protecting you from significant unforeseen costs.

How can a Shelter Island Heights attorney assist with title issues related to older, inherited properties?

Many properties in the Heights have been in families for generations, leading to complex estates and potential title clouds. A local attorney specializes in clearing these titles through quiet title actions or probate proceedings in Suffolk County Surrogate's Court, ensuring you receive marketable title for a property that may have informal or outdated ownership records.

Why Choose a Real Estate Attorney in Shelter Island Heights?

Local Expertise

Attorneys with deep knowledge of New York real estate law and local market conditions.

Proven Track Record

Verified reviews and ratings from real clients in Shelter Island Heights and surrounding areas.

Easy to Reach

Connect directly with attorneys in Shelter Island Heights for consultations and legal guidance.